UPDATE: Printing is working great! Across all major browser. Very happy with the results.
A not so great discovery. So, the site owner uses Safari almost exclusively, unless he needs to test something or be logged in or out in another browser. All printing had been done out of Safari, assuming the result was similar in other browsers. Well, it's not. Safari prints wonderfully, and every other browser I have tried just does a pathetic job. It's really shocking.
However, since most people don't use Safari, another way of either printing, or perhaps creating a pre-composed PDF, is needed. Until a solution is provided, the best suggestion is printing out of Safari, as it really looks vastly better. Like night and day.
You can look at the two printouts from a work-in-progress PC.